Import Car Advertise | Subscribe | Contact Us | About Us

Mitch Schneider: Compound Fracture - Binding Broken Pieces Together to Make our Industry Stronger

April 07, 2010
I was in the car on the way home from work about an hour later than I should have been after a particularly difficult Monday. It wasn't a difficult day, in and of itself, it was me and the difficulties were mine. I was tired, bone tired, and suffering from a bit of sleep deprivation, a problem I've more or less learned to live with over the years. The problem with that particular problem was that tonight I was going to be dealing with the "more" part of the "more or less" a lot more than I wanted to!
Bookmark this website Bookmark this website

I don’t know about you, but for me that kind of tired is especially dangerous. When you are that tired your inhibitions tend to take the evening off, and whatever common sense you might have left is compromised almost instantly. You can actually hear the tumblers clicking inside your head as the dial spins: two turns left to eight – stop; one turn right to 23 – stop; two turns left again to 46 – stop; turn the handle clockwise.

You can feel that last tumbler drop, and almost see the handle move a quarter turn to the right as the vault door in your head slowly creaks open and all your personal demons and monsters, the ones you’ve kept locked away from polite company for so long, come flying past the door howling and screaming like all the hounds of hell — at least, that’s the way it feels.

I have come to find that kind of tired all too familiar. Two parts mental exhaustion, one part physical, one part emotional.

The primary cause of this particular kind of ­exhaustion is juggling. It takes a lot of energy to juggle family, friends, personal relationships, industry responsibilities and your shop responsibilities. I’ll bet you’ve also become just as good at keeping some of those same balls in the air and off the ground.

Add developing two breakfast keynote speeches delivered a few weeks apart and toss in a three-hour management seminar just for good measure, and you have a recipe guaranteed to produce strange thoughts and stranger thinking. So, it wasn’t much of a surprise that’s where my mind wandered, goaded and guided by the same personal and professional demons I ­mentioned just a moment ago.

With no “governor” to restrain it, your mind can race out of control. With the part of your brain responsible for critical thinking dulled by exhaustion and lack of sleep, there is really no telling where that may take you other than the realization that wherever it is, trouble will be right there waiting for you when you finally arrive. Since I’m no stranger when it comes to trouble, that doesn’t frighten me. It probably should...and, it probably would, if I wasn’t always so damned tired. But, it doesn’t.

Consequently, I find myself sitting at my desk, in front of my computer, sharing all of this with you ­instead of crawling into bed where I belong…with the pillow and covers pulled tightly over my head so the monsters won’t find me!

This particular bout of exhaustion was focused on our industry and a host of random observations made, documented and carried forward like the balance in an old general ledger, numbers that seemed suddenly of much greater concern then they have in the past. You see, up until the first two presentations were due, I hadn’t really thought much about the ­industry that exists outside my door for what seemed like a very long time. In fact, with the exception of my writing, I had consciously decided to take a year off and not think about it at all — at least not in the same compulsive, obsessive way I normally do. And, for the most part, I was successful.   

In fact, I was doing fine until I started working on the presentations. And, even then, I was OK…for awhile.

The two keynote speeches had nothing to do with the Industry (Industry with a capital “I”). And, the seminar was all about shop operations and the Cost of Doing Business. It was the “Who” I would be working for that started me thinking about the Aftermarket, our Industry and affiliation in general.

You see, I was working for two large state associations: one here on the Left Coast and the other on the Right. Both are strong and working to get stronger. Both care deeply about their members, the Industry, the Aftermarket and the motoring public. Both are led by lay-leaders: shop owners like you and me. Both are professionally managed. Both are indicative of the many other state, local and national associations working hard to create value for their members, working hard to make this industry better for all of us. And, both are struggling to keep the members they have, struggling to reach out to a new generation of shop owners, a new generation of potential members, in an age in which membership in just about every organization, club or association is steadily declining.

As my mind began to wander, I started thinking about many of the people I have and have had the privilege to know and work with over the years. Virtually all of them had at least one thing in common, they were all affiliated with at least one association. And, then I started wondering, What made them join? What makes anyone want to belong to anything?

What made them work so hard and give so much while expecting so little in return? I found myself wondering why there are so damned many groups and associations to belong to! And, then, I started wondering about how they all survive.

I am not without a little industry association experience of my own. But that personal experience hasn’t helped very much. It seems that even if you were able to achieve some understanding of what is going on here, which isn’t really all that hard to do, it’s likely you will still find yourself struggling with the why!

Even if you account for ego, the “what” is still really all about giving back: helping others and leaving a legacy for those who will follow you. That’s about as easy to understand as it is ever going to get.

It’s the “Why” I consistently seem to have a problem with. Why is the service industry as fragmented as it is? Why are there so many different associations trying to accomplish the same goals and objectives? Why are we so fractious, so unwilling to listen, so quick to go our own way? Why are so few involved when so many could benefit so much from their knowledge and experience? And, most of all, Why does it have to be this way?

Some people would have you believe that we take the “independent” in Independent Shop Owner too literally. But is that really it?

Others would have you believe that it is unreasonable to expect all of us to agree on everything, that ­diversity is healthy. But, as far as I can tell, the only thing that is unreasonable is our inability to recognize and respond to the key issues crippling our industry…as an industry.

You would think that as much as things have changed and as difficult as it has become to achieve success in our industry today, someone would have discovered how much easier it would be if we could speak with just one voice — one clear and unified voice, a voice so loud, with numbers so large, and a force so great — we would no longer be ignored.  

I see the world in pictures and think in metaphors. What I see when I look at our industry is simple. This industry is broken. It is suffering from multiple fractures and lacerations that have left us weak and ­unable to stand on our own. These compound fractures are severe, leaving the structures that might otherwise add strength and stability to our lives, shattered. Left to heal by itself and without proper care, the only thing any of us can be sure of is that the end ­result will be less than satisfactory, an industry left deformed, weak, less than whole.

Is it because no one understands? I don’t think so.

Even our ancient ancestors realized that a broken bone had to be set before it could heal properly. They understood thousands of years ago that those broken pieces had to be moved back into place and aligned with one another. They knew those broken pieces had to be bound together so they could grow together.

If they recognized and realized these simple truths thousands of years ago, it’s hard to understand how or why it is impossible for us to recognize and respond to them today.

The solution is simple, the call to ­action clear: Bring those broken pieces together so they can heal; bind them together to help make them stronger.

If you have never affiliated, find an association that you can work for and that will work for you and then join it. Identify the shop owners within that group who might benefit from your experience and teach them, at the same time, allow those shop owners who are farther along the path you have ­chosen to help teach you.

If you are already affiliated, reach out to those shop owners in your area who have not yet found sufficient reason to join you and give them a reason. Show them the difference associational involvement can make, demonstrate its relevance.

If you are a leader already involved in an association, reach out to the other associations in your area or across the country working hard to achieve the same goals and objectives for our industry you are. You don’t have to join them to join with them.

And, perhaps, that’s it. Perhaps, the time has come for us to create an association of associations that ­understands a compound fracture that is set correctly, bound tightly and allowed to heal properly is in the end stronger than one never stressed or tested. Perhaps, it is time for us to focus on the things we can fix, the things we can change, while putting aside the issues that divide us.

Perhaps, it’s time we realized that while we don’t always have to agree on everything in order to act, we do have to act in order to save ourselves and our industry.

Submit a Comment   Comments (16)
Comment by:
Mitch Schneider
4/26/2010
8:13 PM
Thanks, Bobby



Let me share with you something I wrote to a shop owner who emailed me here at the shop address and not through the magazine. He wanted me to know how hard he tried and how disappointed he was that no one seems to care. I wrote back to him suggesting that we don't need 'everyone.' We just need a small number o of very motivated people willing to work hard to 'push' their respective organizations (whatever they might be) to work together.



With highly motivated people moving in the same direction exerting pressure on key influencers we must might be able to get better traction. With better traction; more results. With better results; more participation. With more participation: a different result. with more positive results... You get the idea.



All it's going to take is each of us leaning on the groups... the "Tribes"... we both belong to and lead.



I'm a firm believer in the: "Do anything! Even if it's wrong!" philosophy. Some action or result is better than the status quo we all endure every day, isn't it?



Mitch
Comment by:
Bobby Likis
4/23/2010
4:39 PM
Mitch said: It's going to be all about "US!" Tom Piippo said: "If we don't do it, it won't get done."

And another week has passed. Is that all there is? Are we waitng for Mitch's next article? Have we fallen or are we simply passing time until "our time" brings us to an end?



Comment by:
Mitch Schneider
4/16/2010
3:29 PM
Thanks again, everyone. Not sure what to say other than this is the response I was hoping for and, Tom... I couldn't have expressed my thoughts any better than you just did... It's going to be all about "US!"



Thanks, guys... Now, all we have to do is get it done!
Comment by:
Tom Piippo
4/12/2010
6:27 PM
No, we don't need more Schneiders (no offence, Mitch) we need to pack a lunch, roll up our sleeves and get to work! This ain't gonna be easy. It all starts and ends with US. There isn't any 'other guy' to let do it. You and I are the 'other guys'. If we don't do it, it wont get done.



If you don't belong to an association, join one. If you have a choice of more than one, the choose wisely. Is this group just a supper club? Have they addressed issues and followed them through? If you, as a shop owner have a better idea, then you should be prepared to present it to a group/ association, and have a follow-up plan to help see it carried through. It's really tough for one man to do alone, but with a group, all working together, it should be a piece of cake.



Years ago I saw the need to join an association and did. I soon saw the benefit to get involved on a state level, and I did. now I have the opportunity to be involved at the national level, and I will.



I challenge anyone who is not a member, to become one. If you are already a member, then become more involved, volunteer for a position or committee. If you already are active in an association, congradulations! Our job is just starting...
Comment by:
TheGoddessAtWork
4/12/2010
6:13 PM
BRAVO!



g
Comment by:
bob gittleman
4/12/2010
10:18 AM
the problem is lots of talk but no action we need more Schniders!!!!!!

keep up the good work
Comment by:
Gonzo
4/10/2010
9:09 PM
Mitch, I couldn't agree more. Industry standards for shops is a great start. In my book I sent you I covered this subject (pg 168) I know it ain't much... but it's an idea. I'd like to see some uniformity in the industry... because like you said... we're getting older... and if there is anybody out there, that knows what needs to changed...it's shop owners like ourselves. let's try before we're all to old to do anything about it.
Comment by:
Mitch Schneider
4/9/2010
12:43 PM
First, I want to thank each of you for taking the time to write. It's always reassuring to know that the thoughts that keep me up at night are shared by others - especially, others I have a deep respect for.



Now, the question is: What do we do about it?



I've said for years that if this industry was a vehicle and ANY of us was riding in it, we'd pull over, stop, raise the hood and try like hell to fix it... Again, the question is: Why hasn't that happened and what do we do about it?



My suggestion is simple - at least, it's simple to state it: execution and implementation may require a little effort. OK, a lot of effort!



Get all the associations together, decide what needs to get fixed first and then go to work... all of us together! When there were lots of Schneiders at Schneider's Automotive each of us would create our own "To Do" list and then lay them out side-by-side. The items that floated to the top would get addressed first - might not be my most critical "To Do," but if it appeared on more than one list regardless of position, it would get handled before something that only appeared on one list. There are issues that transcend personal, regional or local considerations. What are they? What can we do to address them? What can we do to RESOLVE them?



As far as I'm concerned, all reasonable suggestions will be taken seriously. Let's do something: ANYTHING! I'm getting old(er) and I think this would be a hell of start to the kind of legacy all of us would like to leave...



That's what I think... What do you think?
Comment by:
Rick Davis
4/9/2010
12:21 PM
I have been reading Mitch's articles/editorials/rants since somewhere in the 80's. I have never thought that he missed the point. In fact this article(in connection with his prior article),argues a point which we (as a group) have to decide whether we will let congeal until (again) it is taken away from us.

I remember one of his articles from a long time ago in the Simi Valley in a EPA far away where he was depressed because he had to worry about perfect control of waste while the local cable was telling anybody that wanted to do car repair was nothing more than let it run in the street. That's what you are paying Taxes for.

But I digress.......

As far as I can believe, we do know what we are doing.

We do feel that we are doing the right thing for our customers.

We are willing to concede that we are wrong when so, but we want to learn from our mistakes and improve ourselves.

After all of this, I think that mitch's point is "Why can't we agree on what is right? Why is so much of our time spent on stupid wastes of time. Is it wrong to feel that we should have the rights of dedicating our lifes to fixing cars, the liberty of doing it the right way, and the pursuit of the happiness of the customers when it does work.

It is not what we know is right, it has changed to what is believed to be right.

And this is where we have failed.
Comment by:
Carl Lynch
4/9/2010
8:34 AM
Hi Mitch. You hit the nail on the head. With all the problems think about this industry we need to some how fix it. Yesterdays phone call brought up another problem that needs to be addressed, a shop owner or mechanic at another shop in another town telling one of my customers that I put on junk brake pads on the customers car. I dont know who this guy is and I doubt if he knows me yet he evidently knows more than anyone else. Great article Mitch. Carl Lynch
Comment by:
Jeff
4/8/2010
4:35 PM
I have researched several organizations. But which to join? Will my membership be taken seriously? At what cost(when the budget is so tight)and what is the benifit? As Bob Likis stated above as long as the "freebies" exsist we wont be taken seriously. Is there an association that will STOP the corner parts store from giving an inacuarte "diagnosis" and then tell the customer the reapir facitility was wrong. Sign me up, but Where?
Comment by:
Jeff Layman
4/8/2010
4:23 PM
Mitch,great thoughts,what do we do about it & where do we start? keep up the good work
Comment by:
Bobby Likis
4/8/2010
4:05 PM
You've been reading my mail, Mitch. Your notes reach deep into the concerns and challenges that abound for our industry. Until we, collectively, create value for our services, consumers will not change their beliefs. I hope the organizations you prepared your presentations for realize the value you brought their members. Stay the course.
Comment by:
John Tartaglione
4/8/2010
3:42 PM
Mitch

I hear you and I hope that your next article will highlight what a technician sees as the industries most important broken parts. I'll bet they are different than current popular opinion.
Comment by:
Nick Modesti
4/8/2010
3:25 PM
Thanks Mitch...very true and nicely put.

Nick Modesti
Comment by:
Nick Modesti
4/8/2010
3:25 PM
Thanks Mitch...very true and nicely put.

Nick Modesti
Submit a Comment   Leave A Comment
Name   (Required)
Email   (Required, never displayed)
Comments

Please enter the text from the above text box

 
© 2010 Babcox Media
3550 Embassy Parkway, Akron, OH 44333
330-670-1234
(FAX) 330-670-0874